Mediating Complaints Against Nurses: A Consumer-Oriented Educational Approach

Abstract

A participatory evaluative method was used to assess the effectiveness of mediation as carried out by the College of Nurses of Ontario. Qualitative methods were used to examine 34 cases between 1994 and 1998, of which 23 had been successful and 11 aborted. For purposes of comparison, the researchers developed a template of interviews with College personnel and documents, incorporating the College's philosophy and expectations of the process. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 44 participants in the mediation process. In addition, focus group sessions were held with Investigators and Practice Consultants. The data were analyzed using the template and themes were generated. The process was found to be stressful for all parties but was also found to be educational, to address system complaints, and to achieve initial goals. The College was found to be powerless to demand system reforms and to be dependent on the cooperation of each facility.